The reasons behind shelby steeles opposition to affirmative action

He promises to follow her home as soon as he can arrange his affairs, and it looks like he will be good to his word. They are more interested in representation thanin ideas. Thus, he did not confuse the charisma of the protest identity with real achievement.

In that way, the affirmative action strategy has seeded its own frustration. Blacks can have no real power without taking responsibility for their own educational and economic development.

I believe they do this because of what happened to white and black Americans in the crucible of the sixties, when whites were confronted with their racial guilt and blacks tasted their first real power. He has already found in Paris the freedom blacks are fighting for back home.

And when the object of that love is Connie, Eddie begins to see a point in responsibility to the group. That particular measure is controversial, as are many of the other ideas now gaining ground in the states under the personal responsibility banner.

But the movie ends on his promise rather than on his action. They illustrate the fallacy of trying to open all doors with one key: Yet in the American political system, where the powers that be turn a skeptical eye toward any program aimed at economic redistribution, progressives must secure whatever redistributive measures they can, ensure their enforcement, then extend their benefits if possible.

The obvious irony here is that we have become inadvertently invested in the very condition we are trying to overcome. Assuming that we have the power to sustain or even expand affirmative action, do we want it as a transitional institution that will at some point wither away?

Liberals who give only lip-service to these ideals, trash the policies in the name of realpolitik, or reject the policies as they perceive a shift in the racial bellwether, give up precious ground too easily. There is talk now that Congress may pass new legislation to compensate for these new limits on affirmative action.

I think there is something of a Faustian bargain in this. Today no black intellectual in America, including this writer, is safe from this sort of inflation. Now I see them as figures of pathos. Fewer blacks go to college today than ten years ago; more black males of college age are in prison or under the control of the criminal justice system than in college.

In this case, it also represents an attempt to construct sustainable programs that help minorities within a moral framework acceptable to the majority of voters.

And they do so even as the sand is disappearing under our feet on such issues as regressive taxation, layoffs or take-backs from workers, and cutbacks in health and child care.

The political power of big business in big government circumscribes redistributive measures and thereby tilts these measures away from the have-nots and have-too-littles. Back then I thought of being black as a fate, as a condition I shared with people as various as Duke Ellington and the odd-job man who plowed the neighborhood gardens with a mule and signed his name with an X.

If I had been old enough to join the fight for racial equality in the courts, the legislatures, and the board rooms in the s I was old enough to be in the streetsI would have favored -- as I do now -- a class-based affirmative action in principle.

Much like Wilson, he has avoided criticizing affirmative action, even while advancing what amounts to a successor agenda. What form of affirmative action does Steele believe will truly contribute to black empowerment and progress?

Whites cast the vast majority of votes in this country, and they have never accepted programs that give preference to minorities, even when they are presented as recompense for past discrimination.

In this way, affirmative action nurtures a victim-focused identity in blacks. Thus, this young man must also nurture the idea of a black psychological woundedness that is baroque in its capacity to stifle black aspiration.

For far too long candid debate on racial policies within progressive circles has been stifled by undue touchiness and undue hesitancy to reconsider left-liberal conventional wisdom.

Race, Liberalism, and Affirmative Action

Paris is freedom; America, interminable humiliation. This desire would exist and should exist regardless of the state of poverty among African Americans. Abigail Thernstrom, and Dr. And the fact must be borne by the individual as a condition apart from the explanation, apart even from the fact that others like himself also bear this condition.

Without soft-pedaling his own ideas, Starr shows respect for the ideas of those with whom he disagrees and invites them to engage in a vigorous, contentious, but disciplined dialogue with him.

The anger this truth engenders impedes any effective way of responding to the crisis in black America. The Negro world of that era believed that whites used our race against our individuality and, thus, our humanity.

During the long legislative fight over the civil rights bill George Bush finally signed into law last fall, many congressional Democrats felt the political cost of defending affirmative action greatly exceeded the benefits such programs would actually bring to the minority community.

Thomas Sowell and classicist Dr. At worst, the majority of Americans do not see blacks as fully human or members of the political and social community, stereotypical ascribing to them genetically generated moral and mental deficiencies. We cannot be sure that the discriminatory impulse in America has yet been ashamed into extinction, and I believe affirmative action can make its greatest contribution by providing a rigorous vigilance in this area.

Adherence to the Baldwin model is usually more a sin of thoughtlessness and convenience than of conscious avarice, though it is always an appropriation of moral power, a stealing of thunder. It now seems clear that the Supreme Court, in a series of recent decisions, is moving away from racial preferences.A research fellow at the conservative Hoover Institution at Stanford University and a prominent critic of affirmative action, Steele is the author of "White Guilt: How Blacks & Whites Together Destroyed the Promise of the Civil Rights Era" (HarperCollins, $).

Shelby Steele: Shelby Steele is probably not because I'm against the use of racial preferences, affirmative action. So that--that political position, in effect, denies one--one's.

The Reasons behind Shelby Steele's Opposition to Affirmative Action PAGES 2. WORDS 1, View Full Essay. More essays like this: affirmative action, shelby steele, gap between whites and blacks.

Not sure what I'd do without @Kibin - Alfredo Alvarez, student @ Miami University. Shelby Steele is opposed to affirmative action (as it exists today) based on the two premises, that it hurts the people it is trying to help and avoids fixing the problems that hinder blacks and other minorities to.

“Affirmative action is protectionism for the best and brightest of Black America,” Steele said. Dr.

Diversity in Graduate Education: Looking at — and Beyond — Admissions

Abigail Thernstrom, who with her historian-husband Dr. StephanThernstrom has recently written a book about race in America, describedrace-conscious affirmative action policies as a failure.

Affirmative Action 1 Affirmative Action May 6, Affirmative Action 2 What would the business world be like with no affirmative action? One can only imagine the discrimination that would be going on.

The reasons behind shelby steeles opposition to affirmative action
Rated 5/5 based on 75 review